Welcome to our online metaphysical store!

I’m Greg, the webmaster here—and more importantly, part of the family and coven behind everything you see.

We also run a physical shop in Hamilton, Ohio, called Coexist – The Alternative Path. Most folks just call it “The Coexist Store.” It’s a family-owned business and a safe space for all walks of life. Whether you shop online or visit in person, we want your experience to feel magical.

We strive to be the best online metaphysical store. We aim to offer outstanding customer service. Because your input matters, let us know how we’re doing. Contact us anytime. We understand that finding quality magical tools is important. That’s why we carry a wide selection. We also know price matters. While we can’t compete with giants like Walmart or Amazon, we do our best. Often, our prices are better.

Use the search function at the top of our site to find exactly what you need. It’s quick, convenient, and helps you discover the right magical tools or supplies with ease.

Our Metaphysical Store Online

Maybe you’re just exploring witchcraft and paganism. Or maybe you’re already deep in your magical path and need new supplies. Either way, we welcome you. If you’re a seeker, I invite you to explore my blog, Witchcraft – A Metaphysical Blog. But be warned: I’m known for being a bit sarcastic. Some posts may even help you choose the right supplies.

I handle the online tarot readings myself. Sometimes my daughter, Megan, or a trusted reader like Luna will step in. All readings are done by those listed on the appointment booking page. These are live video tarot sessions. You see us. We see you. Payments are processed securely through PayPal or other trusted platforms. This helps keep our readings honest.

Because pagan paths are diverse, we offer goods from Celtic, Norse, Viking, African, Haitian, and Egyptian traditions—and many others too. That way, you can find items that reflect your heritage, tradition, or magical curiosity.

Connect with us on Instagram, Facebook (Meta) or TikTok. We often post specials, deals, and discount codes there. So, don’t forget to follow us if you love savings.

A Metaphysical Website Worth Exploring

We carry over 6,000 products in our online metaphysical store. That’s a seriously wide selection! Because customer needs evolve, we constantly add new items for pagan and occult practices. Therefore, we do our best to keep our offerings fresh and affordable.

We offer a huge range of altar supplies. You can explore athames, cauldrons, ritual bells, chalices, and drinking horns. We also carry altar cloths and a massive variety of incense. Choose from resin, cone, rope, powder, and backflow incense. We have censers and burners to match every type.

Want to set up a personal altar space? We offer altar tiles, deity statues, pentacles, and offering bowls. You can personalize your sacred area with unique items that reflect your beliefs and aesthetics.

I’m especially proud of our occult books section. It just keeps getting better. We receive new titles every week. Books are a great way to dive into magic, spirituality, and witchcraft from many cultures and traditions. Similarly, we offer a broad selection of tarot and oracle decks. We even have a special section for tarot books and other divination methods.

If you’re curious about astrology, numerology, or palmistry, we’ve got books and tools for those too. Because we know that spiritual practices often intertwine, we do our best to carry well-rounded resources.

A Metaphysical Store Online for Crystals

Our metaphysical store online features genuine crystals, although we’re more than just a crystal shop. Choose raw or tumbled stones. Pick small pieces for your pocket or larger ones for rituals or display.

We also stock free-form crystals and shapes like towers or obelisks. While you’re browsing, check out our crystal pyramids.

We offer crystal gift sets and bulk flats that weigh from one to several pounds. These contain several pieces. If you run a shop or sell at markets but lack a wholesale license, this option helps bridge the gap.

Another handy feature? Crystals by metaphysical properties. Because they’re sorted this way, it’s easy to find exactly what you need.

We also offer crystal grids and kits designed for specific intentions. Whether you’re manifesting abundance or seeking clarity, we’ve got sets to support your goals. And for those who love DIY, we have crystal chips and bead strands for crafting your own magical jewelry or charms.

An Online Metaphysical Shop for Candles, Oils, and Herbs

If you’re like me, you go through tons of candles. That’s why we carry so many! We have charged ritual candles inscribed in Theban by a practicing witch. We also stock charged pillar candles for various intentions. You’ll find Reiki candles, chakra candles, and ritual candles for all kinds of magic. Check out our beeswax, votive, container, and jar candles—some even include crystals. Don’t forget to browse our figure candles. We try to keep those in stock.

Because aromatherapy is essential to many practices, we carry hundreds of essential oils. We offer multiple trusted brands. We also stock bulk essential oils.

A proper metaphysical shop needs a solid herb cabinet. We have a wide selection of magical herbs for sale. We stock magical herbs in one-ounce or two-ounce packets. Need more? We also sell one-pound bulk herbs. Because people often ask which herbs support which intentions, our site lets you browse by magical properties.

We also carry herb accessories. Need finer or powdered herbs? We have grinders and gorgeous mortar and pestle sets.

Want to take your herbal magic further? We also sell spell oils, tinctures, resin blends, and incense blends. Many of these are handcrafted with intention and charged under moonlight or specific planetary hours.

An Online Metaphysical Store for Jewelry

Who doesn’t love magical bling, right? Our online metaphysical store offers plenty of jewelry. We carry several genres: Norse, Viking, Wiccan, and more. Accordingly, our jewelry comes in many types and styles. You’ll find amulets, pendants, bracelets, anklets, earrings, and rings—all at affordable prices.

Show off your pagan pride or wear jewelry for energy work. Many witches use jewelry to boost healing and protective energies.

Our pieces come in all kinds of materials. We stock genuine crystal jewelry and sterling silver options. Prefer copper, bronze, or pewter? We carry those too, especially because many men like those styles.

If you prefer to create your own necklaces, we also offer cords, crystal cages, and sterling silver chains. Want to mix fashion and function? Look for our jewelry sets that include corresponding spell intentions or affirmations.

Magical Convenience

We also offer affordable ritual spell kits. These kits are designed for specific intentions and include everything you need to perform your ritual.

We have spell kits for love and soulmate magic. If things don’t work out, we also have justice kits. You’ll find options for money, abundance, purification, protection, and other goals.

We offer special full moon and new moon kits. These may include selenite, candles, salts, magical herbs, and charms.

Additionally, many folks enjoy a hot bath—why not make it magical? Try our ritual bath kits. Beyond love and money spells, we carry elemental bath kits too. These honor Earth, Air, Fire, and Water.

We also offer witch bottle kits, spell scrolls, and intention bundles for those who like compact rituals. And for beginners, we include easy instructions to help you feel confident in your spell work.

Thank You for Visiting Our Metaphysical Website

Thanks for stopping by and exploring our metaphysical website. If you didn’t find what you needed or have a question, contact us. We insist you be happy with your purchase. If something’s wrong, just reach out. Customer service matters to us. It’s our privilege to serve the pagan community. Blessed Be.